Vanilla Around the World: A Tasting Guide

Vanilla may be one ingredient, but it doesn’t always taste the same. When you think of vanilla, you probably picture a familiar flavor profile: sweet, warm and aromatic. But vanilla is surprisingly nuanced. The variety of vanilla bean, where it’s grown, and how its natural characteristics are preserved can all contribute to the flavor in your extract.

Discover four distinct vanilla origins and explore the unique flavors, aromas and pairings each brings to the table. From the classic sweetness of Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla to the warm spice of Mexican Vanilla, the rich cocoa notes of Ugandan Vanilla and the floral, fruity character of Papua New Guinea Vanilla, each origin offers a unique nuance to the recipes you make. Let’s taste our way around the world!

Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla

Classic | Delicate | Sweet

Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla offers the classic vanilla flavor you know and love. It has a balanced, naturally sweet character that makes it a versatile cooking companion. You can use it in a wide range of recipes, from creamy desserts to cookies to chocolate and fruit-forward treats.

  • Try it with: Chocolate, caramel, cream, fresh fruit, and warm spices
  • Explore it in: Ice cream, custards, cakes, cookies, and classic vanilla desserts
  • Try a recipe: Strawberry Vanilla Bean Trifle

Mexican Vanilla

Deep | Spicy | Warm

Vanilla has deep roots in Mexico, and Mexican Vanilla brings a distinctive warmth to the ingredient. With deep, spicy notes reminiscent of nutmeg and clove, it pairs beautifully with other warm and aromatic flavors. Reach for Mexican Vanilla when you want to add depth to a recipe or complement ingredients that already have a little spice of their own.

  • Try it with: Cinnamon, nutmeg, chocolate, nuts, and caramel
  • Explore it in: Spiced desserts, chocolate recipes, seasonal treats and rich baked goods
  • Try a recipe: Baked Bunuelos with Anise Filling

Ugandan Vanilla

Rich | Dried Fruit | Cocoa

Ugandan Vanilla offers a rich and distinctive flavor profile with notes of dried fruit and cocoa. The depth of flavor it offers makes it a go-to for recipes with bold flavors, and the vanilla can add another layer of complexity.

  • Try it with: Dried fruit, dark chocolate, berries, brown butter, and coffee
  • Explore it in: Chocolate desserts, coffee drinks, fruit-forward desserts, and richer treats
  • Try a recipe: Brown Butter Chocolate Snickerdoodles

Papua New Guinea Vanilla

Floral | Fruity | Woodsy

Papua New Guinea Vanilla offers a distinctly different vanilla experience. Nielsen-Massey’s Papua New Guinea Vanilla Extract is made exclusively with Vanilla tahitensis beans, a variety known for its thicker, juicier beans and unique flavor characteristics.

The result is an aromatic vanilla with floral, fruity, and woodsy notes, with a hint of licorice. Nielsen-Massey’s proprietary cold extraction process helps preserve the distinctive character of the beans. Its unique profile is especially delicious with creamy, chilled or frozen, and aromatic recipes—use it to experiment with vanilla beyond traditional desserts.

  • Try it with: Coconut, chocolate, coffee, fruit and cream
  • Explore it in: Frozen desserts, pastry creams, chocolate desserts, coffee drinks, and cocktails
  • Try these recipes:

No-Churn Coconut Vanilla Ice Cream
Vanilla Budino
Flourless Mocha Cake with Crème Anglaise

Taste the Difference at Home

Want to experience the unique character of each vanilla? Make a simple whipped cream and taste them side-by-side. Whipped cream is an easy way to experience the subtle differences between vanilla origins because there are only a few ingredients and nothing else competing with the vanilla’s flavor.

Here’s how:

  • Prepare a batch of unsweetened or lightly sweetened whipped cream.
  • Divide the whipped cream into four equal portions.
  • Add ¼ of the vanilla called for in your recipe to each portion, using a different vanilla origin in each.
  • Gently fold to combine, then taste the four samples side by side.

As you taste, pay attention to the aroma, first impression and finish. Is one sweeter? More floral? Warmer or spicier? Do you notice notes of fruit, cocoa, or wood?

Next, try each with yogurt and fresh berries, chocolate pudding, or even in a cup of coffee to see how the different vanilla profiles interact with other flavors. You may be surprised by just how much the character of a recipe can change simply by switching the vanilla!

Close Icon

Become aVANILLA VIP

Sign up to receive Nielsen-Massey news, recipes, promotions and more.

Related Blogs